Best Nintendo Switch and PS5 Controllers for Comfort and Value
Third-party and first-party controllers from $20-$75 that fix drift-prone stock sticks and add comfort for long play sessions.
* We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. Learn more.
Stock controllers are the first thing serious players upgrade, whether it’s because a Joy-Con developed stick drift or a DualSense just isn’t comfortable for a four-hour session. This guide covers five picks from about $20 to $75 across Switch and PS5, split between budget replacements, comfort upgrades, and genuine performance controllers.
1. First-party PS5 DualSense — best for haptic feedback and adaptive triggers
Sony’s own controller remains the only way to get the full haptic feedback and adaptive trigger experience many PS5 titles are built around, and buying a second one solves local co-op without cutting a cable or fighting over one pad. Prices fluctuate more than most accessories, so this is worth tracking rather than buying at list. Expect $50-$75.
2. Budget third-party Switch Joy-Con replacement — best for fixing stick drift cheaply
Joy-Con drift is common enough that a full first-party replacement pair often costs more than the console warranty is worth, and a well-reviewed third-party pair with Hall-effect joysticks (a magnetic sensor type that resists the wear pattern causing drift) solves the problem for less. Look specifically for “Hall effect” or “drift-free” in the listing. Budget $25-$40.
3. Pro-style Switch controller — best for handheld comfort on long sessions
A full-size, ergonomic pro controller solves the cramped-hand problem Joy-Cons create during extended play, with proper grip contours and a longer battery life than the console’s built-in Joy-Con charge. This is the pick for anyone who mostly plays docked rather than handheld. Expect $30-$65.
4. Budget wireless PS5-compatible controller — best for a backup or kids’ pad
A third-party wireless controller built for PS5 compatibility covers the basics — button mapping, wireless connection, decent battery life — without the DualSense’s premium haptics, which makes it a sensible second or third controller for a household with multiple players. Look for one that explicitly lists PS5 (not just PS4) compatibility. Budget $20-$35.
5. Controller charging dock/stand — best add-on for multi-controller households
A dual charging dock keeps controllers topped off between sessions and eliminates the tangle of charging cables behind a TV stand, which becomes genuinely useful once a household owns more than one controller per console. Most run on USB power and fit both first- and third-party controllers. Expect $15-$30.
How to get the best price
- Set a price-tracking alert on first-party controllers specifically — DualSense and Switch Pro controllers rarely discount outside major sales events, so alerts catch the rare dips.
- Bundle deals (controller plus a game, or two controllers together) frequently beat buying pieces separately during holiday sales windows.
- Retailer trade-in credit for an old or drifting controller can offset 10-15% of a new one at stores that run electronics trade-in programs.
- Check third-party Hall-effect models before assuming a first-party replacement is the only fix for stick drift — it’s usually the cheaper and more durable option.
Controllers are one of the few gaming accessories where the cheap fix (a Hall-effect third-party replacement) is often the objectively better long-term buy, not just the budget one, since it solves the exact failure mode that makes first-party sticks wear out. Save the first-party splurge for the controller you’ll actually use daily, and let budget picks cover backups and kids.